• Reports widening operating loss of ZWG34.38 million, up 23.7% from prior period
• Company's recovery strategy hinges on mainly unrealistic bets, including favorable weather conditions and improved electricity supply
• Intense competition from informal sector and economic pressures exacerbate NTS's financial woes

Harare- In the half-year period ended September 30, 2024, National Tyre Services (NTS) reported a substantial decline in both volume and sales figures, attributed to a myriad of factors such as supply chain disruptions and reduced customer base.

On the upside, the company experienced a 67% increase in light truck tyre sales, capitalising on drought alleviation initiatives by supplying tyres for distribution efforts. Furthermore, NTS continues to maintain its competitive edge in the retread market.

On the downside, the company reported a marginal contraction in new tyre volumes, leading to an overall sales volume reduction of 36%, translating to revenues plummeting to ZWG37.6 million from ZWG58.80 million during the comparative half-year period.

The loss from operations escalated to ZWG34.38 million, up from ZWG27.76 million, culminating in a net loss after tax of ZWG36.46 million compared to ZWG34.66 million in the previous period. The widening operating loss incurred by NTS is an indicator of the company's deteriorating financial performance.

The escalation of the loss from operations to ZWG34.38 million, up from ZWG27.76 million, signifies a 23.7% increase in operational expenditures that are not being offset by corresponding revenue growth. This trend is alarming, as it suggests that NTS's core business operations are becoming increasingly unprofitable.

From a technical analysis perspective, the widening operating loss can be attributed to a mismatch between the company's cost structure and its revenue streams. The increase in operating expenses, coupled with stagnant or declining revenue, has resulted in a significant erosion of NTS's operating margins. This has had a cascading effect on the company's bottom line, culminating in a net loss after tax of ZWG36.46 million, up from ZWG34.66 million in the previous period.

The deteriorating financial performance of NTS is attributed to various factors, including declining sales volumes, intense competition from the informal market, and inefficient cost structures which requires NTS's management to undertake a comprehensive review of the company's business model, with a focus on optimizing operational efficiency, reducing costs, and driving revenue growth.

This may involve implementing strategic initiatives such as cost-cutting measures, process re-engineering, and innovative marketing strategies to enhance the company's competitiveness and profitability.

As the preeminent distributor and retailer of new tyres and tubes within Zimbabwe's automotive sector, NTS's strategic focus includes re-lugging tyres for agricultural and earthmoving applications and procuring truck tyres for the national transport industry.

However, despite its dominant market position, NTS faces formidable competition from the informal sector, where services are often offered at significantly lower prices sometimes undercutting NTS's pricing by more than 50%.

This competitive pressure is exacerbated by a challenging economic landscape, with unemployment rates exceeding 40% according to Zimstat, and estimates from non-governmental sources suggesting rates above 80%. This environment has fostered a survivalist mentality among consumers, resulting in a shift toward informal trade and services.

NTS is not alone in facing these challenges as numerous formal enterprises are grappling with similar issues. Unverified gossips indicate that OK Zimbabwe plans to shutter 10 of its stores in 2025 after previously struggling to break even, while TM has expressed concerns regarding the sustainability of its operations in Zimbabwe.

Furthermore, various companies, including Metro Peech was sold, Khaya Cement, and Beta Bricks, have sought corporate rescue, highlighting the perilous state of formal businesses amid increasing market substitution by informal alternatives.

Zimplow has also closed several Trentyre branches, citing intense competition from both formal and informal players, hence a need to operate a lean structure and reduce costs.

In light of governmental reluctance to intervene and support formal businesses, it falls upon executives to devise strategic responses to mitigate market substitution and operational losses.

NTS's current strategy is centered on achieving a turnaround in its financial performance, following a dismal showing in the first half of FY2025. The company's management is pinning its hopes on a recovery, driven by a combination of strategic initiatives and market factors. This approach is underpinned by the assumption that the company can regain its footing and return to profitability, despite the challenging operating environment.

A key plank of NTS's strategy is the resumption of direct procurement of budget tyre brands from China. This move is designed to enhance product availability and competitiveness, by allowing the company to tap into a broader range of tyre products at competitive prices.

By sourcing products directly from Chinese suppliers, NTS aims to reduce its reliance on third-party distributors and improve its negotiating power, ultimately leading to better pricing and margins.

NTS's recovery strategy is also contingent upon favorable weather conditions, specifically increased rainfall in the second half of the fiscal year. The anticipated rainfall is expected to stimulate agricultural activities, which in turn would revitalize the tyre sector and drive demand for NTS's products and services.

The deplorable state of Zimbabwe's road infrastructure, characterized by numerous potholes, ensures a steady demand for tyre servicing and replacement.

However, NTS's reliance on consumer behavior and favorable weather conditions poses significant risks. Many customers may opt for informal services that offer more competitive pricing, which could erode NTS's market share.

Moreover, the anticipated rainfall has been disappointing, with minimal precipitation recorded in the initial quarter from September to December. This shortfall suggests that the servicing demand NTS projected may fall short of expectations, which could have a negative impact on the company's financial performance.

NTS is counting on improved electricity supply to reduce operational expenses, which is contingent upon rising water levels in the Kariba Dam. However, as of December 2024, water levels remained critically low, below 4%, which further jeopardizes the company's financial recovery plans.

The confluence of unfavorable factors has cast a shadow of uncertainty over NTS's recovery strategy, underscoring the imperative for the company to devise contingency plans to mitigate these risks. As the company's strategic initiatives falter, competitors are seizing the opportunity to thrive, while the informal sector continues to flourish.

This disparity in performance shows the need for NTS to reassess its operational framework and explore alternative avenues to curtail operational costs and enhance sales performance.

To regain its competitive edge, NTS may consider rationalizing non-profitable branches or optimizing their profitability, ensuring alignment with pricing structures of informal market competitors.

 This strategic realignment would enable the company to remain competitive in a market where informal traders and formal competitors are offering similar services at significantly lower prices.

NTS must develop unique value propositions that distinguish its services from those offered by other retailers, thereby creating a compelling reason for customers to choose NTS over its competitors.

Ultimately, NTS's management must adopt a proactive approach to steering the complexities of the market, where competition from both established rivals and the informal marketplace is intensifying.

Equity Axis News